|
Implied Bids and Offers
Matching Partial Orders
National Markets and Marketmaker Responses
Entered orders may be executed against one or more existing internal orders,
against bids and offers in the traditional markets, against marketmaker's
directed responses to an entered order, or against a combination of these.
Internal order matching is more complex than for traditional orders because
the ratio of buy quantity to sell quantity is held constant, even if an
order does not trade in its entirety.
An important part of the liquidity in the BarterSecurities system is what is
known as "Implied", or "Virtual" Bids and Offers. Consider the two
orders in Table 1:
Table 1
|
Order #1 |
Order #2 |
| Security A | Buy 1000 |
| Security B | Sell 1000 | Buy 1000 |
| Security C | | Sell 1000 |
| Overall Dollar Limit | Pay up to $2,000 | Pay up to $1,000 |
|
(Note that the limit prices for each order is in the form of an overall
debt/credit to the trader rather than in the form of individual stock
prices. To learn more about these types of order limits click
Limit and Market Orders .)
Taken together, security B nets out and the orders in Table 1 are equivalent
to:
    Buy 1000 A / Sell 1000 C / PAY up to $3,000.
In other words, the orders in Table 1, taken together, provide an Implied
Bid of $3,000 for a barter order to Sell security A and Buy security C.
Now suppose that an order to Sell 1000 A and Buy 1000 C is submitted with a
limit to Receive $4,000 (instead of receiving $3,000, which would cause a
trade to take place). Then three orders reside in the BarterSecurities
system, as shown in Table 2.
Table 2
|
Order #1 |
Order #2 |
Order #3 |
| Security A | Buy 1000 | | Sell 1000 |
| Security B | Sell 1000 | Buy 1000 | |
| Security C | | Sell 1000 | Buy 1000 |
| Overall Dollar Limit | Pay $2,000 | Pay $1,000 | REC $4,000 |
|
Now there are three Implied Bids and Offers:
- (Orders #1 + #2)
Buy 1000 A / Sell 1000 C / PAY up to $3,000
- (Orders #1 + #3)
Sell 1000 B / Buy 1000 C / REC at least $2,000
- (Orders #2 + #3)
Sell 1000 A / Buy 1000 B / REC at least $3,000.
How wide is the market in Buying A and Selling B? Order #1 is $2,000 bid
for that combination and an implied order (#2 + #3) is $3,000 ask for the
same combination, so the market is $1,000 wide.
Note that as new orders are added to the system, the number of implied bids
and offers can increase as fast as geometrically if the incoming orders
involve many of the same securities.
While internal order matching may involve multiple parties, some orders may
have to be only partially filled to effect a trade. For example, consider
the barter orders in Table 3, without regard for applicable limit prices:
Table 3
|
Order #1 |
Order #2 |
Order #3 |
Order #4 |
Order #5 |
| Security A | Sell 200 | Buy 400 | Sell 300 | | Buy 300 |
| Security B | Buy 400 | Sell 400 | | | |
| Security C | | | Buy 200 | Sell 200 | |
| Security D | | | | Buy 200 | Sell 300 |
|
Within the BarterSecurities model an order can be executed in part only if
both legs are filled on a prorata basis. Therefore, orders #1 and #2 cannot
directly be used to effect a trade in Security B (even though they represent
a buy and a sell of 400 shares of B) because Security A cannot be matched in
a proportional way to both orders.
However, the BarterSecurities system, using a patent-pending methodology,
computes that a combination of partial fills leads to matched trades for
each security. In Table 2 below the Fill Ratio is the fraction of each
order that is traded. For each respective order, it is multiplied by the
delivered buy and sell amounts in Table 1 to generate the executed buy and
sell amounts in Table 2. In the rightmost column of the Table 2, the traded
securities are totaled and are seen to net out to zero for each security.
Table 4
|
Order #1 |
Order #2 |
Order #3 |
Order #4 |
Order #5 |
Net Amt. |
| Fill Ratio | 1/2 | 1/2 | 1 | 1 | 2/3 | |
| Security A | Sell 100 | Buy 200 | Sell 300 | | Buy 200 | -0- |
| Security B | Buy 200 | Sell 200 | | | | -0- |
| Security C | | | Buy 200 | Sell 200 | | -0- |
| Security D | | | | Buy 200 | Sell 200 | -0- |
|
The liquidity of the internal matching system is enhanced by exploiting the
bids and offers for individual securities that reside in the traditional
markets. That is, a NYSE or Nasdaq offer at the right price to sell 200
shares of Security A could be combined with the original Orders #1 and #2 in
Table 1 to complete a three-way trade.
Notwithstanding the richness of the internal order matching capability, many
orders will be executed against marketmakers who make a directed response to
an order. Although it is infeasible for marketmakers to post continuous
bids and offers for two-dimensional orders as they do for traditional
orders, the BarterSecurities system provides them with a
toolkit that they can use to deliver automatic,
instantaneous responses to orders according to the risk characteristics of
the order (e.g., industry closeness of the buy- and sell-side stocks, stock
liquidity, etc.) Accordingly, a Limit Order Book
for any barter order can be populated for trading in real-time.
|